After the dreadful blast in Lincolnshire in which five men lost their lives, we can expect lots of outrage about illegal immigrants, illegal alcohol production, tax evasion, poisonous drinks and much more.
One thing that we will not hear anything about is that if you pay twenty quid for a bottle of vodka, about £13.50p of that price is tax. For the manufacture, wholesaling, distribution and retailing of your vodka you have paid £6.50p. That includes all the raw materials, labour, diesel and everybody’s profits. For doing precisely nothing, the government has taken twice as much as the people who were responsible for getting your vodka to you.
This is not enough for the anti-drinking lobby. They are lobbying to have minimum prices fixed for booze so that you will have to pay even more for every unit of alcohol that you buy. This is despite the fact that Britain has higher alcohol taxes than most countries.
You all know the supposed justification. Excessive drinking is damaging to health and ‘binge’ drinkers are responsible for crime and disorder. Advocates of minimum pricing claim that 3,000 lives each year could be saved if a minimum price of 50 pence per unit were imposed.
In my view the people who are trying to tell us how to live our lives are talking complete rubbish as usual. First of all, the people whose lives are substantially shortened by their alcohol consumption are generally very heavy drinkers. This is not a case of going a bit over nanny’s guidelines, but those who consume high alcohol volume drinks for most of their waking time. A significant proportion of these people have actually made a decision to end their lives with the help of alcohol or they suffer from a serious medical condition (not alcoholism, which may be an aspect of personality but it is not a disease) which makes it very difficult or impossible for them to manage their alcohol use. It should be self evident that pricing will have very little effect on these drinkers although it may mean that they are more likely to engage in crime to be able to maintain their alcohol intake.
The other effect of excessive taxation of alcohol is that the production or import of untaxed products will increase. This will in turn have several effects. The two most significant ones are that low grade drinks will cause very much more serious health damage than those retailed through reputable outlets and so far as price is significant at all, those who buy the very cheap, untaxed products will be able to drink more. When covert distilling goes wrong, which it is bound to do because of the inadequate skills and materials of those doing it, the health consequences are terrible. Blindness, paralysis and death are outcomes which can occur from a single drinking bout with contaminated products.
As we have seen at the industrial unit in Boston, when the state makes it worthwhile to create a black market in distilling there can be other tragic consequences too.
Related articles
- Illegal alcohol clue to death blast (mirror.co.uk)
- Five killed after explosion at suspected illegal vodka factory in Lincolnshire (mirror.co.uk)
Posted by malpoet 



