You shall have no other gods but me.
So this god, who was supposedly talking to Moses and giving him a set of rules, is worried about competition. Followers of the Abrahamic faiths claim that there is only one god and that god is all powerful. This first commandment actually acknowledges that there are other gods, but the god of Moses’ first instruction to humans is that they must accept him as their god. It seems like a very insecure position for an all powerful god to take doesn’t it?
Some might argue that this is an inadequacy of language or translation and that god is unique and just giving the instruction for people to acknowledge that. That does raise the amusing question of what language does god speak. Is it Aramaic, Hebrew, Greek, Latin, Arabic? In which language were the stone tablets inscribed? A pre-hebrew desert semitic dialect?
Anyway, let’s get back to the heart of it. If there is only one god there is no possibility that anybody shall have another one so the commandment is pointless. If it is an insistence, as it is taken to be, that people should not worship false gods why doesn’t it say that? If the Abrahamic god is all powerful and the only god anyway, why does it matter if people have mistaken beliefs in non existence gods. Why doesn’t an all powerful god make his human creation undertand that there is only one god. There are a host of more realistic options for this god than to give an instruction that people shall have no other god but him.
The truth, of course, is that Moses did not talk to god. There were no tablets of stone handed down from the deity. There was no god giving such silly instructions. The commandments are human made. They are products of their time and of no relevance to twenty first century humans other than as subjects for academic study.
Posted by malpoet
Posted by malpoet
Posted by malpoet